10 top-rated roof replacement companies near Menasha

We ran a Google Maps search for roof replacement companies near Menasha, WI and kept the ones that passed our screen. The 10 that made it average 4.9 stars on 1,090 reviews combined. That ranking skips the license question entirely, so confirm the paperwork directly with Menasha's roofer before any money changes hands.

Google Maps ratings checked October 1, 2026 · How we rank

1974median year homes were built

Homes in Menasha

Half the houses in Menasha were built before 1974, per Census Bureau estimates.

57% of the city's housing units went up before 1980, old enough that many are on a second or third roof.

That's part of why 10 roofing contractors keep a listing here for Menasha.

Data: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates, table-based Summary File (2024 table-based Summary File) (2024 table-based Summary File).

10 top-rated roofing contractors in and near Menasha

Sorted highest first by a Google rating weighted against how many reviews back it; that sort isn't a license check, so confirm the paperwork yourself.

Top-rated roofing contractors in and near Menasha, WI, with Google ratings
Rank	Business	Google rating	Reviews	Category	Area	Google Maps listing
1	Nickols Roofing & Gutters	5.0 out of 5 on Google	148	Roofing contractor	Neenah 54956	Google reviews
2	DuraShield Roofing & Contracting	5.0 out of 5 on Google	109	Roofing contractor	Neenah 54956	Google reviews
3	Romportls Contracting LLC	5.0 out of 5 on Google	107	Roofing contractor	Neenah 54956	Google reviews
4	Advantage Exteriors, LLC	5.0 out of 5 on Google	106	Roofing contractor	Menasha 54952	Google reviews
5	Upward Exteriors Roofing	5.0 out of 5 on Google	89	Roofing contractor	Appleton 54914	Google reviews
6	Home Pro Roofing	4.9 out of 5 on Google	146	Roofing contractor	Neenah 54956	Google reviews
7	Appleton Roofing Solutions	5.0 out of 5 on Google	49	Roofing contractor	Appleton 54911	Google reviews
8	Andra Contracting	4.9 out of 5 on Google	49	Roofing contractor	Appleton 54914	Google reviews
9	Rosenow Customs LLC	4.8 out of 5 on Google	160	Roofing contractor	Neenah 54956	Google reviews
10	Great Lakes Roofing Corporation	4.8 out of 5 on Google	127	Roofing contractor	Menasha 54952	Google reviews

Questions to ask before you sign

Can you show me your license or registration number, and does it match what's on file with the state?
Will you pull the roofing permit yourself, and will you give me the permit number once it's issued?
How many existing layers are on my roof now, and does that allow a recover under the building code, or does it need to come off?
What's the full written scope: materials, brand, quantity, start date, and payment schedule?
What does the manufacturer's warranty cover, separate from your own workmanship warranty?
Who is responsible if a subcontractor or material supplier on my job goes unpaid?

Other cities in Wisconsin

All cities in Wisconsin →